The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Through Hollywood’s Eyes
From Exodus to Munich and Miral, Hollywood told the story of Israel and the Palestinians largely from one side. Social media is changing what its stars will say.
During the latest crisis between Israel and the Palestinians, social media filled with unprecedented campaigns of solidarity with the Palestinians, condemning Israel’s operations. For the first time those campaigns drew Hollywood celebrities and stars such as Mark Ruffalo, Viola Davis and the Israeli-born Natalie Portman. For the first time, too, statements of support for Israel from Hollywood stars were absent, with the exception of a tweet by the Israeli actress Gal Gadot, which met with scathing criticism and whose comments she later switched off.
Exodus and the Zionist epic
Until recently, any statement in support of the Palestinians or critical of Israel exposed Hollywood stars to fierce condemnation from their fans and a rebuke from Hollywood’s executives, and sometimes wrecked their careers. That is because Israel, from its founding, built close ties with Hollywood and its executives, most of whom were Jewish, in order to promote itself as a peaceful, civilised democracy struggling against a backward Arab world. The first fruit of those ties was Exodus, made by some of Hollywood’s most prominent figures: the screenwriter Dalton Trumbo, the director Otto Preminger and the international star Paul Newman. It was shot in Israel.
The film offers a Zionist account of Israel’s founding through the story of a ship called Exodus, carrying European Jewish immigrants who survived the Holocaust. It docks in Palestine despite British efforts to stop it, and its passengers settle in the country’s towns and countryside. After the United Nations announces the partition of Palestine between Jews and Arabs, the Arabs attack them savagely and kill their women and children. They defend themselves with courage and valour until they defeat the Arabs and found the state of Israel.
The film, which came to be known as a Zionist epic, is considered one of the most commercially and critically successful in Hollywood’s history. It left an enormous mark on American public opinion: it strengthened Americans’ support for Israel and their backing for Zionism, and created a negative view of Arabs, who appeared as hostile savages lacking civilisation.
The emergence of the Palestine Liberation Organisation on the world stage, and its demand for Palestinian rights after Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza in 1967, drew the attention and sympathy of the Western media. That put Israel in an awkward position. It had lost its standing as the victim of the Arabs, and the Palestinians had become its victims.
Matters soon turned, and Israel regained the identity of the victim, after the Palestinian group Black September took Israeli athletes hostage at the 1972 Olympic Games and killed them during the attempt to free them. The Western media turned on the Palestinians, who came to be portrayed in every Hollywood film as terrorists who hijack planes, kill innocent Jews and rape their women.
Vanessa Redgrave stands alone
Even so, those years produced the first film star brave enough to stand with the Palestinians: the British actress Vanessa Redgrave, who made the first film about the Palestinians, The Palestinian. She faced campaigns of condemnation and received threats from Zionist groups and Hollywood filmmakers, and her career suffered. She held her ground, even after a bomb exploded outside an American cinema before the premiere of The Palestinian.
When Redgrave was nominated for an Oscar in 1978 for her performance in Julia, she faced a fierce campaign from members of the Jewish Defense League, who demonstrated outside the ceremony. She won all the same, and in her acceptance speech denounced them as “Zionist hoodlums”. The phrase was met with boos from the audience. The celebrated screenwriter Paddy Chayefsky then rebuked her, to warm applause, saying she should have said thank you and kept quiet, and stopped using the Oscars to promote her ideas.
When I spoke to Redgrave two years ago, she told me that things had changed a great deal in people’s awareness of the Palestinian cause, although the Palestinians have yet to win their freedom. We cannot rely on governments to bring about change, she warned, because they are unable to do so. Ordinary people matter most, she said, and the question of Palestinian rights has come to matter to ordinary people everywhere.
Munich, Miral and Natalie Portman
Hollywood’s view of the Palestinians began to change gradually in the late 1990s, after the Oslo accords between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organisation, and with the outbreak of the second intifada at the start of the millennium, which received wide coverage in the Western media and exposed the Palestinians’ tragedy. Palestinian cinema also emerged, through the films of directors such as Elia Suleiman, Mohammad Bakri and Hany Abu-Assad, which presented Palestinian reality from a Palestinian point of view for the first time and inspired filmmakers around the world.
In 2005 Hollywood’s master, Steven Spielberg, released Munich, which follows a Mossad team hunting members of Black September in revenge for the Munich massacre. Its Palestinians are people like any others, fighting for freedom and dignity, while the Israelis kill the guilty and the innocent alike in pursuit of revenge, which leads the head of the Mossad team to doubt the morality of their operations.
Israel and Zionist groups in the United States condemned the film and called for a boycott. What angered them most was that Spielberg, known for his love of and support for Israel and his loyalty to Zionism, humanised a Palestinian fighter and gave him the chance to speak of his pain and his dream of returning to Palestine. Munich was the first Hollywood film in which a Palestinian character speaks rationally, which contradicted the Israeli account of the Palestinians as hostile savages.
In 2010 the producer Harvey Weinstein and the director Julian Schnabel, both Jewish, made the first Hollywood film told from the point of view of a Palestinian character: Miral, adapted from the novel by the Palestinian journalist Rula Jebreal. It chronicles a Palestinian orphanage founded by Hind al-Husseini, from the Nakba of 1948 to the first intifada at the end of the 1980s, through the story of an orphan named Miral who joins it in the 1970s.
Miral, unlike Munich, buckled under the assault of Zionist groups in the United States, which protested against its premiere at United Nations headquarters in an effort to stop it. Several Hollywood organisations, among them the Hollywood Foreign Press Association, refused to attend its screening in Hollywood. In the end the film failed with critics and at the box office. The same fate met A Tale of Love and Darkness, which the Israeli-American Hollywood star Natalie Portman adapted from the book by the left-wing Israeli writer Amos Oz.
The film is set in Palestine in 1947 and tells the story of a European Jewish family who find safety and peace alongside their Arab neighbours in Jerusalem, until war breaks out between the two sides after the partition of Palestine. The Jews are victorious, yet the founding of Israel brings them neither security nor happiness.
Later, Portman refused to attend the ceremony for the Genesis Prize she had been awarded in Israel, in protest at the Israeli government’s conduct. She went on to denounce the Jewish nation-state law, in an interview I conducted with her at the end of 2018, calling it racist.
What social media changed
It is one of the ironies of this story that among the most important catalysts for the change in Hollywood’s approach, and in the way its stars, Jewish and otherwise, see the Palestinians, is social media. It broke down the official barriers between the facts and the audience, and so shook the Israeli narrative that prevailed in the traditional media, just as it shook the racist narrative about Black people in the United States and forced Hollywood to embrace diversity and avoid stereotyped portrayals of minorities and the vulnerable in its films. That change will undoubtedly affect how Americans see the Palestinians, and help them understand their cause.
Sources: Deadline; Jewish Telegraphic Agency; Al Jazeera; Deadline (2011).
More on UKScreen
Cinema · 2013Natalie Portman to direct an Israeli movie – Interview
Cinema · 2013Lebanese and Iranian Directors take the spotlight at the Jerusalem Film Festival.
Cinema · 2021The Other Israel Film Festival: Hammered by Israel’s Friends, Shunned by Palestinians
Politics · 2022Israel’s Supporters Use Slander to Silence Palestinians in HollywoodMost read on UKScreen
- A Cannes Master Made a Film With No Actors or Crew. Only His Vision Survived
- Trump Survived His Scandals. So Who Wanted Nvidia’s Jensen Huang Gone?
- What Was Russell Brand Truly Punished For?
- Ellison’s Empire Sends Hollywood a Message About Israel
- Johnny Depp Is No. 1 Again. Hollywood’s Forgiveness Was Always for Sale
Get the best of UKScreen by email
New stories, reviews and interviews from the archive, straight to your inbox.
6 Comments
Comments are closed.