Skip to content
London · Since 1999
Cinema

Netflix Faces a $150 Million Trial Over Baby Reindeer’s “True Story”

Netflix will face a jury in May 2027 over five words, "This is a true story". Hollywood's dramatists explain why the rest of the industry says "based on" instead.

Richard Gadd as Donny Dunn, in a yellow coat, sitting on a bus in front of a misted window with reindeer antlers drawn on it, in Baby Reindeer.
Richard Gadd as Donny Dunn in Baby Reindeer. Photo: Netflix

Five words could cost Netflix $150 million. Baby Reindeer opens with the line “This is a true story”, and on 18 May 2027 a jury in Los Angeles will decide whether it was. Judge R. Gary Klausner has set the trial date in Fiona Harvey’s defamation suit against the streamer, after an appeal court threw out Netflix’s attempt to kill the case.

Harvey, a Scottish woman, says she is the real model for Martha, the stalker who torments Richard Gadd’s alter ego, Donny Dunn. The series shows Martha twice convicted, sent to prison, sexually assaulting Donny and attacking him with a glass. Harvey says she has never been convicted of anything. Netflix denies defaming her, calls the show a dramatised account and says the stalking and harassment allegations are substantially true. Gadd, who is not a defendant, told the court: “Martha Scott is not Fiona Harvey.”

A promise or a premise

The case turns on a distinction every screenwriter knows and most viewers never notice. “Based on a true story” and “inspired by real events” announce an adaptation: real people and real events, with invented scenes stitched between them. “This is a true story” makes a promise. Gadd’s own stage version, performed in Edinburgh in 2019, used the softer wording. When the story moved to Netflix, the premise hardened into a promise.

Klausner noticed. The opening line, he ruled in 2024, “invites the viewer to take what is presented to them as fact”. Then he wrote the sentence that may decide the trial: “There is a major difference between stalking and being convicted of stalking in a court of law.”

The Coen brothers turned that promise into a joke. Fargo opens with “This is a true story. The events depicted in this film took place in Minnesota in 1987.” Not a word of it was true, and nobody sued, because nobody in it existed. Martha has a living model, with a face, a home and a television interview with Piers Morgan.

Netflix has paid for this lesson before

In 2020, Britain’s then culture secretary, Oliver Dowden, asked Netflix to tell viewers that The Crown was fiction. Netflix refused, saying it had “every confidence our members understand it’s a work of fiction”. Two years later, season five arrived billed as a “fictional dramatisation”. Netflix settled Linda Fairstein’s suit over When They See Us by donating $1 million to the Innocence Project, and in February it resolved Rachel DeLoache Williams’s suit over Inventing Anna. In Britain, the makers of The Lost King paid damages last year and added a disclaimer calling their portrayal of a university official fictional.

What the dramatists told me

Over the years I have put the same question to the filmmakers who turn real lives into drama. Every one of them described a bargain with the truth, and none called the result a true story.

Peter Morgan, who created The Crown, told me the official records tell him where the royals were on any day of any year. “What we don’t know is what they were thinking and feeling,” he said. “That needs a dramatist to invent it from his imagination.” Danny Boyle called his Steve Jobs film “our interpretation”, made by keeping some facts and throwing out “other facts that get in the way of telling the story”. Oliver Stone trusts “my sense of the truth”. Quentin Tarantino kept his memory’s mistakes in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood because “it stayed part of the memory”.

Those who came closest to living people were the most cautious. Adam McKay kept Vice hidden from the Cheneys, fearing they would go to court to stop it. Clint Eastwood made Richard Jewell, about an innocent man destroyed by a reckless story, and then faced the charge that his film smeared a real reporter, Kathy Scruggs. “Just when you think you know everything,” he told me, “you realise that sometimes you know nothing.”

Emotional truth on trial

Gadd has described Martha as an emotionally true portrait. Emotional truth is a playwright’s measure, and it won the series six Emmys. A courtroom uses a blunter one: a conviction either happened or it did not. Gadd’s Edinburgh audience was told the story was based on his life. Netflix’s global audience, tens of millions strong, was told it was true, and some of them went hunting for the real Martha within days.

That is the irony at the heart of the case. Netflix put “This is a true story” on screen because truth sells. Viewers believed the label, and that belief turned a dark comedy into a global sensation. If the jury finds those five words false, every streamer will rewrite its opening titles, and “based on” will become the most valuable phrase in television.

More on UKScreen

Most read on UKScreen

  1. A Cannes Master Made a Film With No Actors or Crew. Only His Vision Survived
  2. Johnny Depp Is No. 1 Again. Hollywood’s Forgiveness Was Always for Sale
  3. Trump Survived His Scandals. So Who Wanted Nvidia’s Jensen Huang Gone?
  4. The Awkward Boy Who Fled Blockbusters Is Now James Bond
  5. The Wachowski siblings (formerly brothers) seek the meaning of life in Cloud Atlas
The UKScreen Letter

Get the best of UKScreen by email

New stories, reviews and interviews from the archive, straight to your inbox.

Discover more from UKScreen

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading