Skip to content
London · Since 1999
Cinema

Martin Scorsese on The Irishman, Joker and the Fight for Cinema

Martin Scorsese tells Husam Sam Asi why he made The Irishman, stepped away from Joker, and fears for filmmakers’ place in a Hollywood dominated by superhero blockbusters.

Husam Sam Asi with Martin Scorsese
Husam Sam Asi with Martin Scorsese. Photo: Armando Gallo.

In his new film, The Irishman, veteran director Martin Scorsese returns to the world of Italian-American organised crime through the story of Frank Sheeran, a meat-delivery truck driver who befriends Mafia boss Russell Bufalino and becomes his right-hand man and hired killer.

Impressed by Sheeran’s professionalism and loyalty, Bufalino introduces him to the famous Teamsters union leader Jimmy Hoffa. Hoffa takes him on as an aide and bodyguard, then as an intermediary between himself and the Mafia bosses. Sheeran’s influence grows until he becomes a powerful union official, but he remains subject to the Mafia’s authority. In the film’s account, that loyalty ultimately leads him to kill Hoffa.

The story and its central character recall Scorsese’s Goodfellas, which also follows a young man drawn into the Italian-American underworld. Yet where the gangsters of Goodfellas enjoy extravagant lives and lavish their wives with expensive clothes and jewellery, the men of The Irishman inhabit a darker world, spending much of their time in dimly lit bars.

The character comes first

Scorsese has explored American organised crime, both Italian and Irish, in other films, including Casino and The Departed, the latter winning the Oscars for Best Director and Best Picture. But when I spoke to him last week at the Four Seasons Hotel in Beverly Hills, he stressed that what draws him to a film is its characters rather than the world they occupy.

At this stage of his life, he explained, he had chosen to invest his time in this character and this world because they reflect so much of life itself: moral conflicts, struggles with power and the darker reaches of human nature. These are questions about which he remains curious, and which he wants to explore through characters and actors.

Again and again, he said, the situation is personal: a man or a woman may be a good person, yet circumstances eventually lead them to do bad things.

Scorsese introduces Sheeran as a frail elderly man looking back on his life from a nursing home. His account takes us back to his service in the Second World War, when he learned Italian and participated in the killing of German prisoners. His command of the language and his familiarity with violence later help him find a place in the Italian-American Mafia.

Through Sheeran’s eyes, the film presents a period of American history spanning the 1950s to the 1970s. It depicts Hoffa using union pension funds to finance Mafia activities and portrays alleged Mafia involvement in John F. Kennedy’s election, preparations for the failed invasion of Cuba and Kennedy’s assassination after relations with his administration deteriorate.

These events are drawn from Charles Brandt’s book I Heard You Paint Houses, based on Sheeran’s account of his life. Sheeran claims to have played a central role, but the credibility of his stories has been widely challenged. Critics have suggested that he invented claims to make money from the book. Scorsese’s interest lies elsewhere.

The character attracted him, he told me; the historical story forms the background. Whether Sheeran did everything he claimed remains open to argument. Scorsese chose to put the character at the centre and make him representative of that world—a world that, in turn, reflects the larger world of American history.

Television screens in the background carry reports of jury tampering and the Cuban missile crisis. The characters may have connections to some of those events, but the forces operating around them remain difficult to comprehend. Even where an account is not strictly factual, Scorsese believes that a close exploration of what might have happened can reveal another kind of truth.

Finding the rhythm of a three-and-a-half-hour film

Martin Scorsese talks to Husam Sam Asi about The Irishman, Joker and the future of cinema.

Scorsese is accustomed to making long films, often running beyond two hours. The Irishman lasts about three and a half hours. Despite concerns about the shrinking attention span of contemporary audiences, he has not shortened his films. Instead, he has sought a different way of telling the story and holding the viewer’s attention.

The screenplay’s structure was crucial, he explained, as was filtering the story through Frank. As events become more complicated, they eventually fall away, leaving us with him and the diminishing world around him.

The approach had to feel simpler, even though the production itself was enormously complex: 360 scenes, 120 locations and extensive visual effects. That apparent simplicity helped Scorsese maintain a strong atmosphere of danger and uncertainty.

He described a scene in which Frank stands outside his car at a petrol station, watching women smoke and looking towards Bufalino on the telephone. When the camera returns to Robert De Niro, sunglasses conceal his eyes. Something is wrong. Frank senses it but cannot express it. He believes he is in control, when in fact he is not.

That was the essence of the approach: allowing certain passages and images enough time to communicate without having to state everything in words.

De Niro and Pacino, together again

Husam Sam Asi talking with Robert De Niro during promotion for The Irishman.
Husam Sam Asi with Robert De Niro. Photo: Armando Gallo / HFPA.

The film stars two giants of acting: Robert De Niro, who plays Sheeran and also helped produce the film, and Al Pacino, who plays Hoffa. De Niro has appeared in many of Scorsese’s films, including Casino, Goodfellas, Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy. This is Pacino’s first film with the director, and the third in which he and De Niro share scenes.

Although the two actors have been close since the early years of their careers, they recently told me that their methods differ considerably. Pacino inhabits his character before filming, whereas De Niro prefers to discover it during the shoot.

Scorsese laughed when I put that distinction to him. He had not known it, he said, although he felt that De Niro also takes his time and always has something happening in his head—something visible in his face.

That was one reason Scorsese committed to making the film with him. He had seen something in De Niro’s relationship with the character: a determination not to let him go, and a real understanding of who he was and the conflicts within him.

Scorsese admitted that he does not know how De Niro achieves it. He has never taken an acting class or formally studied acting techniques. His understanding of actors and how to work with them came from watching the films of Elia Kazan and John Cassavetes.

Having never worked with Pacino before, he watched what happened between Pacino and De Niro in front of the camera. Their performances reflected a relationship built over roughly 50 years as friends, colleagues and artists.

Why he stepped away from Joker

Scorsese has recently provoked controversy by arguing that superhero and Marvel films are closer to theme-park entertainment than to the cinema he values: films that convey one human being’s emotional and psychological experiences to another.

There is an irony here. The recent comic-book film Joker draws heavily on two of his own films, Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy.

He acknowledged the connection. He had thought about Joker over a period of four years, he told me, before deciding that he did not have the time to pursue it. He knew the script well and admired its energy and Joaquin Phoenix’s performance.

For Scorsese, however, the character’s eventual transformation into a comic-book figure takes him towards abstraction. That does not make it bad art, he stressed, but it is not the direction he personally wants to take. He also regarded Joker as very different from conventional superhero films.

Superhero films are another artistic form, he said. They are not easy to make, many talented people work on them, and young audiences enjoy them. But he sees them as an extension of the amusement park.

He recalled hearing studio chiefs in the early 1970s talk enthusiastically about bringing a Disney World model into the film business, with studio visits becoming something like theme-park tours.

His concerns centre on access to screens and the place of filmmakers within the industry. Given the revenues superhero films generate, he recognised that studios, companies and cinema owners cannot simply be told to stop earning money from audiences who want to see them.

But they also have a responsibility to give something back to culture. They must make room for filmmakers to show their work, whether in cinemas or through the growing number of streaming platforms. Scorsese believes the industry’s outlook must change if the kind of cinema he makes is to survive.

Netflix takes the gamble

Despite its celebrated cast, The Irishman could not find backing from the traditional Hollywood studios for a production costing an estimated $160 million. Scorsese turned instead to Netflix.

That decision suggests that the future of dramatic cinema may increasingly lie with streaming services, while comic-book blockbusters dominate theatrical screens. Netflix stands to benefit: the film’s early reviews have given it a 99 per cent rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and it is expected to be a major contender in this season’s Oscar race.

Explore more from the archive: UKScreen interview archive · Cinema, Science and the Imagination.

More on UKScreen

Most read on UKScreen

  1. Johnny Depp Is No. 1 Again. Hollywood’s Forgiveness Was Always for Sale
  2. A Cannes Master Made a Film With No Actors or Crew. Only His Vision Survived
  3. The Awkward Boy Who Fled Blockbusters Is Now James Bond
  4. The Wachowski siblings (formerly brothers) seek the meaning of life in Cloud Atlas
  5. Trump Survived His Scandals. So Who Wanted Nvidia’s Jensen Huang Gone?
The UKScreen Letter

Get the best of UKScreen by email

New stories, reviews and interviews from the archive, straight to your inbox.

Discover more from UKScreen

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading